I see you got your list out, say your peace and get out
Yes, I get the gist of it, But it’s alright
Sorry that you feel that way, the only thing there is to say
Every silver lining’s got a Touch of grey
— Jerry Garcia and Robert Hunter
For once in the storied history of this publication, I’m gonna get straight to the point:
Let’s go big.
Let’s cut taxes.
Across the board.
Slash the personal rate in every bracket. Take capital gains taxes to zero. Eliminate the death tax.
Obliterate that gruesome FICA withholding. Or at least that horrifying employer match part.
Discontinue the income tax for New York City residents. Cut state taxes – in New York, Illinois and New Jersey (yes, Jersey).
Do not cut taxes in California (or Oregon or Washington State); in fact, it wouldn’t bother me if you raised them. Even if it is the state of my birth. Despite my having tons of friends, family and even clients out there. Because I don’t like the way they roll in Sacramento (or Salem – where my sister lives, or Olympia) and don’t believe we should encourage such behavior — any more than is necessary in the interest of decorum.
C’mon, Biden, you said that you wanted to go big. And this is the way to do it. I know, you might get some whines from Warren, sobs from Sanders and squawks from The Squad. But let me ask you – who’s running this here show? A soon-to-be-octogenarian curmudgeon from Vermont? A 90-pound female former Harvard Professor? Four Windy Wendy Whiners in the House? Or the guy who once confidently proclaimed he’d like nothing better than to take his predecessor (who outweighs him by at least 5 stone) out back and beat the sh!t out of him?
I’m here to inform you that you’d be delighted with the result. The economy would explode. Innovation, the scope and breadth of which we could only, heretofore, have dreamed, of would materialize. Professor Laffer would (yet again) be proved correct – the government would actually end up collecting more revenues than even the huge pile it is extracting at the moment.
And, whatever fiscal hole was left in the aftermath, the Fed could just print away. After all, it’s what they’re doing now, and how’s that working out?
Yup, great. Especially for the capital economy. After lurching about for 3-4 weeks, the Gallant 500 and its brothers/sisters in arms gathered themselves rather gallantly this week, with the G5 settling just 3 skinny points (0.071%) below its all-time highs. In addition, our Fair Ladies of Adjacent Asset Classes are bestowing their favors in dainty, divine portion, with Madame X yields submerged to 1.55% and Vixen VIX in sweet repose at nearly pre-virus lows: 16.42.
Much of the love came gloriously at the end of the week, in the wake of a May Jobs Report, which, if problematic from certain perspectives, was a received with unmixed delight by market participants.
And all of this before we put into action our jointly devised (yes, I’m willing to even share authorship credits with you) go big/tax cut plan.
Two forming cumulus clouds (a touch of grey), however, loom menacingly on the horizon.
The first is embedded in the above-mentioned Jobs Report, which unfolded in such a way as to corroborate the emerging hypothesis that the United States is, improbably, suffering from a Labor shortage. Just as we are getting the “all clear” to actually leave our houses, the Labor Force Participation Rate is shrinking. Small businesses are nearly uniform in their complaints about their inability to fill open positions. This problem is particularly acute in the leisure and hospitality industries, the annualized 25% increase in median wages for those sectors notwithstanding.
So, the restaurants are full, but the prices are high, and the service is less than lightening quick. That’s OK, honey, because you know what we’re gonna do? We’re gonna take our time, eat slow, and then order a couple of hot fudge sundaes for dessert.
Which brings us to the other pending problem (the silver lining with a touch of grey): Inflation. While there have been, as previously reported, some ebbs and flows in these realms, the directionality of essential commodity prices is unmistakably towards the heavens. West Texas Intermediate Crude Oil closed Friday at five year highs — ~$70/barrel – in striking contrast to that surreal interval last spring, when, for a brief instant, sellers were actually forced to pay up to $40/unit to rid themselves any crude they had hanging around.
Published reports indicate that California (which should not be encouraged) residents could be paying $7/gallon at the pump this weekend. And the driving season has only just begun.
Thus, for typical the wallet-stretched, SUV-driving, non-kosher-keeping, restaurant-preferring Californian (who should not be encouraged), the pressure is illustrated in the following images:
I reckon my CA friends will suck it up, though, because many of them are flush with the incremental cash to assume the extra cost burden.
And the cash keeps coming – from the Fed and from Capitol Hill. The dynamic has reached the point where it is beyond dispute that a) financial institutions will buy unlimited amounts of Treasury paper at a zero percent yield; and b) millions of able-bodied citizens are, on balance, better off spending their days waiting for government checks, and then Driving to Carl’s Jr. (where I hear the service is slow, but we got nowhere we got to get to in a hurry anyway) than they are, tramping off to the job site or office.
The answer? Cut taxes. Big. Across the Board. Maybe even in California.
A theory has emerged in forums not yet banned by Big Tech Overlords that the direct payments to the jobless from the government are a back-door form of raising the minimum wage. Having failed, thus far, in passing a floor of $15/hr. (so the theory goes), the links between subsidized unemployment and labor shortages are a suitable substitute: forcing business managers to pay an equivalent amount (or more) for able-bodied workers.
I’ve no empirical way of testing this hypothesis, but if it’s true, then what better way to energize the strategy than cutting taxes? Hiring managers, facing the high-class but mounting challenge of processing new business flows, would be incentivized to offer deals that might impel even our most dyed in the wool slackers off the couch. Plus, with FICA gone, owners and workers might actually save money – particularly if the former pay their staff in the form of stock options, which, under my plan, would be taxed at zero.
And before you call me out for not attending to it, let’s address the following question. Does the strategy place our two cumulus clouds on a thundering collision course? Or, in other words, would a tax cut be inflationary?
Probably. But I think, on balance, we’d be better off, unleashing the divine benefits of productivity gains and excess demand in a surging economy. There are worse challenges than this to confront in this world, you know.
In addition, a tax cut would show our global trading partners – including China – that we mean business. We might even steal some commerce back from economic juggernauts such as the Ireland or the (soon to be reestablished) Republic of Texas.
It would also be, presumably, accretive to the hard-pressed investment class, but far be it for me to feature this argument. I continue to believe that with gushers of liquidity floating around — of sufficient size to rival the untapped Saudi Oil Fields, opportunities for upside capture exist in growing abundance – with or without a tax cut. It’ll be a little tricky here, but, at the moment, I don’t think markets can’t sell off much, and are more likely to climb to materially higher elevations. Throw in those tax cuts, and, well, one can always dream.
But this proposal is not for professional investors; rather it’s for the masses, those holy recipients of crocodile tears and little else. Cut taxes and they be rockin’.
As for us, well, like I was singing to you just the other night: We. Will. Survive. Which will take some work, but I think we’re equal to the challenge. We’ll start with a trip to Carl’s Jr. But not in (not to be encouraged) California, because the company long ago bounced to the (soon-to-be-reestablished). Republic of Texas.
And so…
The shoe is on the hand that fits, There’s really nothing much to it,
Whistle through your teeth and spit, cause it’s alright,
Oh well a touch of grey, Kind of suits you anyway, That is all I have to say…
Actually, not quite. All I have to say, that is. But the rest of the message I’d like to deliver in person.
Meanwhile, I’m off to do some old-fashioned Washingtonian lobbying, It must (indeed) be getting early and (yes) the clocks are running late. The time has come, in other words, to make my move. I’ll take the Acela bullet train. D.C. is a buttoned up town, so I’m wearing a silver tie with (an obligatory) touch of grey. And, in a final turning of the tables respecting my efforts, and for the benefit of all, I ask you to wish me a sincere…
TIMSHEL